OpenStack providers¶
ethere must not be locked to OVHcloud: a cluster must be deployable entirely on European infrastructure, and also anywhere else an OpenStack public cloud fits. The architecture only relies on standard OpenStack APIs (Nova, Neutron, Glance, Cinder, Keystone) plus S3 — not on the provider's DNS service (Designate or other): DNS is ours (dns.md), only the zone holding the NS names needs a DNS API somewhere, independent of the OpenStack provider; the parts that are provider-specific today (OVH vRack provider_network_type, Ext-Net, flavors, S3 endpoint) must move into a per-provider profile.
Compatibility checklist¶
What ethere actually depends on, to check on each candidate (first item is eliminatory):
- Anycast on Neutron ports: a shared IP answered by several servers needs either
port_security_enabled: falseon the ports (what ethere does today) orallowed_address_pairs. Many providers forbid disabling port security by policy.tests/images/openstack/anycast.test.jschecks it end to end (two carriers, one client, failover when the carrier withdraws the address); it passes on the test cloud (ML2/OVS with l2population: IPv6 neighbor discovery is not proxied, so every carrier answers). Backends that answer neighbor discovery themselves for known port addresses (e.g. OVN) may break it: run the same scenario on a candidate before relying on it. OVHcloud: passes (2026-10-26, by hand with the test's user-data on vRack VLAN networks without port security): two carriers in two AZs of EU-WEST-PAR, a client in the third AZ and one in GRA9 each answered by a carrier, the other carrier taking over when the first one was stopped; the vRack carries one VLAN across regions (a network created in each region with the same segmentation id, the same subnet and disjoint allocation pools: no Neutron knows the other region's ports). - UEFI images: Glance/Nova honour
hw_firmware_type=uefi(and the virtio properties of the images). - Metadata service with user-data (
http://169.254.169.254/openstack/latest/user_data), the ports innetwork_data.json(each one's MAC address, network ID and static addresses or DHCP:sys-apps/ethere-netconfigconfigures the network from it), and the server's metadata inmeta_data.json, updated while the server runs (enrollment through the console returns the certificates there). - IPv6 on public and private networks.
- Console log API (
openstack console log show,os-getConsoleOutput): the nodes' identity relies on it (enrollment through the console,pki.md), and so do diagnostics (no login on the instances) and the tests. - Several availability zones in a region, server groups with (soft) anti-affinity.
- Cinder volumes attachable to instances (applications' persistent volumes).
- S3-compatible object storage (backups, disaster recovery).
- Small cheap flavors (DNS secondaries), and the flavors needed by the cluster.
- Quotas, API rate limits,
clouds.yamlsupport (openstacksdk profile).
The local test cloud (Kolla-Ansible, vanilla OpenStack, etherectl test-cloud) is the reference: what runs there without provider-specific settings should run on any compliant provider.
Provider profile (to design)¶
The OpenStack provider is independent of the registrar and of the host of the zone holding the NS names (see dns.md, "Roles"): they get their own settings. Per OpenStack cloud: network type and external network name, whether port security can be disabled (else allowed address pairs), flavors per role, availability zones, S3 endpoint and credentials, DNS (provider-managed zone API for the NS names, see dns.md), image properties.
European candidates¶
| Provider (country) | AZ | DNS service (not needed) | S3 | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| OVHcloud (FR) | 3-AZ regions (e.g. Paris) and single-AZ regions | own DNS API (no Designate exposed to Public Cloud) | yes | current target; also has non-European regions (below) |
| Infomaniak Public Cloud (CH) | 3 | DNS as a Service | yes (Swift + S3) | OpenStack, reputed cheap; Switzerland (outside the EU, GDPR adequacy) |
| Binero (SE) | 2 (europe-se-1a/1b) |
Designate | yes (Swift + S3) | OpenStack Zed, also Octavia, Barbican |
| Cleura, ex City Network (SE, DE) | Stockholm, Frankfurt, Karlskrona | Designate (~€0.45/zone/month) | yes | rather expensive (~$15/month for 1 vCPU / 1 GB) |
| Elastx (SE) | 3 (3 datacenters 20 km apart) | not confirmed | yes, replicated over the 3 AZ | premium, per-minute billing |
| Sovereign Cloud Stack (SCS) clouds (DE): pluscloud open (plusserver), Wavestack (noris/Wavecon), REGIO.cloud (OSISM), CNDS (artcodix), ScaleUp, Cloud&Heat… | varies | varies | varies | standardized OpenStack (common flavor/image names, conformance tests): good portability target |
| Open Telekom Cloud (DE, NL) | 3 | own | yes | OpenStack-based but heavily customized: lowest priority |
| Others listed by openstacksdk: Betacloud (DE), Fuga (NL), Switch (CH), Ultimum (CZ), Zetta (NO) | to check whether still active |
Non-European candidates¶
| Provider (country) | Regions | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| OVHcloud outside Europe | Canada (Beauharnois), Asia-Pacific (Singapore, Sydney, Mumbai); US through the separate OVH US entity | same APIs as the European regions |
| VEXXHOST (CA) | Montreal, Santa Clara | OpenStack-native provider, upstream contributor |
| Rackspace OpenStack Flex (US) | US and international regions | multi-tenant OpenStack public cloud |
| Catalyst Cloud (NZ) | Porirua, Wellington | OpenStack public cloud |
| ConoHa (JP) | Tokyo, Singapore, San Jose | OpenStack-based |
| DreamCompute (US) | Ashburn | to check whether still active |
These tables come from public pages and the openstacksdk vendor list (2026-10-06): service availability, prices and especially the checklist above must be verified on each candidate; the openstacksdk list includes providers that may no longer exist.
Next steps¶
- Parametrize the OVH-specific settings into a provider profile, and run the provisioning on the test cloud with a "vanilla" profile.
- Test the checklist on two European candidates with trial accounts: Infomaniak (cheap, 3 AZ) and an SCS cloud (standard); Binero as an alternative.
- Later, one non-European provider (e.g. VEXXHOST) to validate deployments outside Europe.
Sources: provider sites (Infomaniak, Binero, Cleura, Elastx, SCS, Wavestack, VEXXHOST, Rackspace OpenStack Flex), the OpenStack public cloud marketplace and the openstacksdk vendor list.